Prismatix

I have added +1 vote for this mapset!

I have added +1 vote for this mapset!

I have just put this mapset on hold, which means that minor issues have been found in the mapset and we are waiting for a fix with a map update. Please fix the listed errors and update the mapset.

Discussed diff naming in #mapping, putting on hold so that the mapset updating is announced in #ranking-queue

I'm not a fan of jumps starting rolls either, but I kept them because they were "consistent", and thought I'd get nailed for omitting them. I've removed the following notes from both diffs: `37210|1 133210|4 147610|4`

Regarding diff names, Kaleid Ruby is the "older sister" to Kaleid Sapphire... If you don't feel that's sufficient justification for the naming, then I'm gonna have to enlist the help of a proper weeb because I have never actually watched the show.

And the anchors, yeah - I saw a few of them, but changing them requires restructuring basically the entire stream section, so I'd rather not touch things there unless someone finds it to be a serious issue.

I have just put this mapset on hold, which means that minor issues have been found in the mapset and we are waiting for a fix with a map update. Please fix the listed errors and update the mapset.

Add "starlog" to tags, as that appears to be the title of the original song
Change the diff names to have a clearer progression (more like representation in this case?) of difficulty

I saw some pretty long anchors in the stream of the harder diff, but they didn't really feel bad to me so /shrug
Personally I dislike the presence of the jumps at `133210` in the harder diff but if you wanna keep it I think it's fine

I have just re-submitted my mapset for rank!

Had another closer look at this (since, you know, it's been 3 months since I made the map) and here's what I think:

1. missing triples like on ``21310|1,21310|4``, taking as reference ``20710|1,20710|3,20710|4``
You are correct. This was an oversight and those hands should have been turned into jumps. Easy enough fix.

2. cutting the structure on ``96010`` when it should fo much longer for not cut the feeling of the music
I have absolutely no idea what you mean. This section is very different from what comes right before if you listen to the music, and the repeated notes represent the sustained vocals. I think you misunderstood the structure here.

3. missing the pitch on the jumpstream of ``105760`` when notes like ``105910|3`` should start on ``105760``
You completely misunderstood the structure for the jumpstream. The idea was to map jumps every 3rd note to represent the movement of the synth. There was never any intent on pitch relevancy, since this is 4k and there just isn't room for that.

4. copypasted pattern when your style is more disordered (which is bad tho, no structure at all
This isn't constructive. And if you were to read #3 and #5, you'd learn that the problem was your misunderstanding, not the lack of structure.

5. the first difficult is the same as the second except its just overmapped on jumpstreams
If you understood the structure of the jumpstream (see #3) then you would have understood the difference. It's not overmapped. It's the same but with additional jumps on each bass kick.

Maybe if you don't understand something, ask next time? The actual errors I recognize were simple enough to fix, and the difference in difficulty between the charts (especially because of the jumpstream) is significant. If push came to shove, I would have been fine dropping one diff and moving it to a new unranked mapset instead.

And yeah no, once I correct issue #1 I'm resubmitting as soon as your queue opens in 2025. Please do better next time.

The difficulties are different, but if you really perceived them as being that similar, then I suppose I have failed in differentiating them.

As for the other listed issues, I agree with a few of what you have listed, but I disagree with others. Additionally, I have seen you guys work with mappers to get things ranked when they have many more issues than what you have listed here, so I can only assume that the difficulties "being too similar" was the nail in this coffin.

Alas.

I will make some edits according to your criticism, but I will not resubmit this mapset.

I have just denied this mapset from being ranked. Please fix the listed errors and resubmit in 3 days.

Structure errors (missing triples like on ``21310|1,21310|4``, taking as reference ``20710|1,20710|3,20710|4``. cutting the structure on ``96010`` when it should fo much longer for not cut the feeling of the music and missing the pitch on the jumpstream of ``105760`` when notes like ``105910|3`` should start on ``105760``), copypasted pattern when your style is more disordered (which is bad tho, no structure at all) (reference: ``139210`` is the same as ``19360``), and most important, the first difficult is the same as the second except its just overmapped on jumpstreams, are enough motives for deny.

I have just put this mapset on hold, which means that minor issues have been found in the mapset and we are waiting for a fix with a map update. Please fix the listed errors and update the mapset.

do not update just yet, its just my own preference that some pair of patterns are not into my liking, currently asking for opinion.


i'll let you know when you should update