I have denied this mapset because:
The mapset contains unrankable difficulties.
song representation is poor at a lot of times in the chart for example in top diff, 126391|1,126391|2,126391|3,126391|4,126521|4,126521|2,126521|3,126521|1 two quads in concession with honestly not much in the music except for the barely pronounced melody sound, adds little depth to this part. Not only that but there are a lot of inconsistencies especially with drums, sometimes you make them like 262434|3,262434|4,262500|2,262500|1,262565|3,262565|4,262630|2,262630|1,262695|3,262695|4 or 262956|4,262956|3,263021|2,263087|1,263087|4,263152|3,263217|2,263217|1 or 254086|4,254086|3,254086|1,254152|2,254217|1,254282|2 which are different patterns from each other. small details like these really make up the coherency of the chart which is what the chart is lacking.
The mapset has incorrect metadata.
remove camellia from tags since its already in the artist field. might also want to add in the tags camellias aliases and "electronic, instrumental"
Additional comments:
right now its a deny but with proper self modding and applying the mods from both me and heki, im sure the map will be in somewhat of a rankable state
Hekireki
3 months ago
the timestamps above are for the Master difficulty
Hekireki
3 months ago
I have denied this mapset because:
The mapset contains unrankable difficulties.
with polishing id be happy to rank a spread like this,
but as of current there are too many inconsistencies in all difficulties.
- 10043|3,10043|2 should be 1 note cuz its just the vocal starting
- 33456|2,33521|1,33586|2 is 1/3
- 33717|1 is a ghost note
- 33913|3,33913|1 should be a hand judging by the same instrument being hands at 31435 for example
( same at 33456|2,33521|1,33586|2,33717|1,33913|3,33913|1)
(same at 41804|3,41869|4,41934|3,42065|4,42260|4,42260|1)
- 33260|1,33391|4,33391|3 there is a burst sound in between here so its mapped to lightly
- 37434|3,37500|2,37500|1,37565|3,37630|4,37695|1,37760|2,37760|3,37826|4,37891|1,37956|4 should be 1/6
- buildup from 46435-54783 is too dense considering its the most quiet part of the buiildup. it should be less dense as the part before and afterwards instead of being the same. (so basically just use jumps instead of hands here)
- 57782|3,57782|2 should be a single note and 58043|2 should be a double, this is a sign of mapping a song fast without paying too much attention to detail. before submitting maps to queue, its recommended to check through the map to spot these kind of issues yourself to raise the change of ranking.
- 58043|2 is a jump for some reason although its the same sound as the other hands
- 59086|2 should be a jump
etc.
this was the first minute out of 6 which makes modding it far too labour intensive :)
you can resubmit basically rechecking and remapping a lot of the inconsistencies but as for now, its not rankable
SirJospeh
5 months ago
I have just submitted my mapset to the ranking queue!