I have denied this mapset because:
The mapset contains unrankable difficulties.
While I agree with Linlime that the chart's concepts are there and the execution is alright, I believe the chart still has a very long way to go before being rankable. To start, the choruses are a bit too lacking. This can be helped with the addition of more Long Notes or some more emphasis on the vocals to make them stand out more from the rest of the chart. This lack of density/attention to detail in the chorus sections also makes the difficulty balancing throughout the chart a bit odd. Alongside this, there are a lot of moments that would increase the quality of the chart if you were to throw in more Long Notes. This is to better emphasize the guitar that you were already charting to, so there shouldn't be anything stopping you from emphasizing it a little more. Take for example the section 88919 - 93719. The usage of LNs here is just fine but had you included more the emphasis you were already putting on the guitar would be more apparent and make for a better flowing structure overall. With all of that being said, it would be wise to comb through the chart and just tinker a bit more with the usage of Long Notes and differing chord sizes to more accurately line up with the instrumental. I believe this can be rankable in the future but as it stands now the entire chart needs a bit of a rework.
REEISNAME
1 month ago
I think I fixed all the consistency issues, but as for drum notes that are weird to not map I didnt really understand where you were referring to. Sorry for that, still pretty new to making maps.
QuaverBot
1 month ago
The creator has just updated their mapset, and its status has been changed back to Resolved.
Linlime
1 month ago
I have on-hold this mapset because:
The mapset's timing is incorrect, and requires an offset or additional timing point(s).
Its a liveplay so its a little annoying to sync perfectly which is not expected. however I feel +8 to the offset is just a little nicer balance between most drums
There are issues with one or multiple difficulties in the mapset.
Mapset concept overall seems to be quite clearly heavily drum focussed with some supporting guitar and keeping it easy/simple. however there are a few patterns in the map that dont really fit the easier concepts like 83669|1,83669|4,83744|3,83744|2,83819|4,83819|1,83894|2,83969|4,83969|3 is a big offender. Super dense and super over the top in compare to basically the entire rest of the map.
Furthermore there are a few consistency issues in chord sizing which I want to emplore you to look over before i come back to check.
Another consistency thing i found is the guitar mapped 33719 in compare to it not being mapped at 43319 which repeats in the next section
Lastly the guitar solo part has many noticable drums not mapped or places where there are no drums notes mapped which seems weird for the focuss of this map and also does not accurately follow the guitar
There are unnecessary files in the mapset folder.
Files seem to contain both a unused banner and background
Additional comments:
Please fix these and then I'll recheck with more indepth modding later
netzoid
2 months ago
u need a language tag
REEISNAME
2 months ago
I have just submitted my mapset to the ranking queue!
