I have denied this mapset because:
The mapset contains unrankable difficulties.
banger song
but the map needs alot of tweaking. i will give you some examples below
map needs 23ms offset
-the intro would better represent the song if you only strictly mapped the dominant guitar and drum sound instead of adding filler notes
-44497|4,44497|2,44497|1,44590|3,44684|2 why is this the only case where the guitar sound is accurately mapped compared to 8497,14497 or anywhere up to this point. by doing the point mentioned above and mapping all guitar accurately it would make for a much more crisp playfeel.
- adding to netzoids mention of inconsistent layering:
48247|4,48434|4,48622|4,48809|4 vs 51247|3,51434|3,51622|3,51809|4 vs 60247|2,60434|2,60622|3,60809|4 vs 63247|3,63434|3,63622|3,63809|3 you notice that the anchors, general diffculty of the patters are very different and also doesnt change according to the pitch change in guitar for example, the difficulty of the pattern should be consistent for similar sounds, (anchors are much harder to execute than rolls for example)
- in the main part from 72247 the layering of the jumps doesnt really correspond to the vocals or drums or guitars and is a bit inconssitent and would be better to have a clear structure like single note guitar, double for guitar and drum and loud drum hand or use consecutive doubles for consecutive drums etc.
72434|2,72434|3 and 73559|3,73559|2 the second has drum but is the same density, it would represent the song better if these had densities according to the total instrumental instensity
72809|2,72809|1 no drum double, 75059|2,75059|1 same density altough drum is more prominent
-since the current version all guitar sounds are doubles why arent 79184|2,79559|2 too?
i can give you more in-depth explanation if you want on discord
netzoid
2 months ago
I have denied this mapset because:
The mapset contains unrankable difficulties.
multiple inconsistencies throughout the chart especially with layering, chordsize, etc. numerous playability issues throughout the song like noticeable hand biases such as 47099|4,47286|4,47474|4,47474|2,47661|2,47661|4,47849|3,47849|4,48036|3,48036|4,48224|2,48224|4,48317|3,48411|4,48505|2,48599|3,48599|4,48786|4 that are really uncomfortable and hard to hit adn the music context does not justify this
Additional comments:
feel free to me me on discord (yuikonnu) for further details on this deny
7xbi
4 months ago
I have denied this mapset because:
The mapset contains unrankable difficulties.
Chord sizes are the biggest issue in this map. As Linlime already mentioned, the chord sizes often time feel rather random even though the songs intensity changes.
> 48974|1,48974|4,48974|2,49349|1,49349|2,49349|3,49724|4,49724|2,49724|3,50099|3,50099|2,50099|1 etc. shouldn't be hands as it's not the same intensity as the sound 48599|1,48599|3,48599|4 before.
> 96786|3,96786|4,96786|1 there shouldn't be a hand here. Theres no significant change in the song that would justify the hand here. This goes for every other repetition of this issue
Overall, with most of the chord inconsistencies throughout the map, it is currently in an unrankable state.
The mapset has incorrect metadata.
The gamemode does not have to be specified in a difficulty name unless the mapset has both 4K and 7K difficulties, otherwise this is not needed
Linlime
4 months ago
I have denied this mapset because:
The mapset contains unrankable difficulties.
The concept of the map is solid however I feel the execution is still poorly done. the chosen chordsizes in sections are not the right choice. also the map sometimes is very expressive with following the guitar but other times just completely ignores it for seemingly no reason.
Ganon130
5 months ago
I have just submitted my mapset to the ranking queue!
